How a Tiny Isotope Revealed the Secrets of a Criticality Accident
On September 30, 1999, a flash of blue light illuminated a fuel preparation room in Tokaimura, Japan, marking the beginning of the worst nuclear criticality accident in the country's history.
Workers at the JCO fuel fabrication facility had inadvertently created a supercritical mass of uranium, triggering an uncontrolled nuclear chain reaction that lasted for hours.
Scientists faced a crucial question: exactly how much nuclear fission had occurred? The answer would determine the scale of contamination and guide cleanup efforts.
When uranium fissions, it produces Barium-140 (Ba-140), which then radioactively decays into Lanthanum-140 (La-140) with a half-life of 12.75 days. The La-140 subsequently decays with a much shorter half-life of just 1.68 days 1 .
The La-140/Ba-140 activity ratio serves as an exceptionally reliable timer for nuclear events. The specific ratio reveals exactly how much time has passed since fission occurred 1 .
| Isotope | Half-Life | Role in Analysis | Radiation Emitted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ba-140 | 12.75 days | Parent nuclide | Beta particles |
| La-140 | 1.68 days | Daughter nuclide | Gamma rays (1.596 MeV) |
| U-235 | 700 million years | Fission source | Various |
Workers were preparing fuel for an experimental fast breeder reactor by mixing uranium powder with nitric acid—a process that normally should have been performed in dedicated facilities with proper criticality controls .
They inadvertently added approximately 16.6 kg of uranium to the tank—far exceeding the critical mass for the geometry and concentration involved .
At 10:35 AM on September 30, the mixture reached criticality, initiating a self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction that continued intermittently for approximately 20 hours .
Uranium in precipitation tank
Duration of criticality
From acute radiation syndrome
Researchers employed passive gamma-ray spectroscopy to investigate the accident. This technique involves measuring the natural radioactive emissions from materials without stimulating them further .
The key measurements focused on detecting the characteristic gamma rays emitted by La-140, which has a distinctive energy signature at 1.596 MeV (million electron volts) 3 .
The distinctive 1.596 MeV gamma ray from La-140 provided a clear fingerprint that scientists could detect amid other radioactive materials.
Gathering environmental samples from the accident area
Using high-precision germanium detectors
Converting gamma rays to quantitative measurements
Calculating total fission events from measurements
Total fission events estimated during the JCO criticality accident
| Property | Value | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Ba-140 fission yield in U-235 fission | ~6.2% | High abundance enables accurate measurement |
| Time to reach radioequilibrium | ~3-4 weeks | Ideal measurement window |
| Characteristic La-140 gamma energy | 1.596 MeV | Clear identification possible |
| Dating precision | ± few hours | Accurate event timing |
These sophisticated instruments can distinguish between gamma rays of slightly different energies, allowing scientists to identify specific radioactive isotopes through their unique gamma-ray "fingerprints" 3 .
The combination of detectors, shielding, and analytical software that converts raw radiation measurements into identifiable peaks corresponding to specific isotopes.
Methods for separating and preparing samples to improve measurement accuracy, particularly important when dealing with complex mixtures of fission products.
Computer programs that simulate the growth and decay of radioactive isotopes over time, allowing researchers to work backward from measurements to event reconstruction.
| Tool Category | Specific Example | Function in Analysis |
|---|---|---|
| Radiation Detection | HPGe Detectors | Identify and quantify specific radioactive isotopes |
| Shielding Systems | Lead castles | Reduce background radiation for clearer measurements |
| Analytical Software | Gamma spectrum analysis programs | Convert raw data into isotopic activities |
| Reference Materials | Calibrated radioactive sources | Ensure measurement accuracy |
| Sample Preparation | Radiochemical separation equipment | Isolate isotopes of interest from complex mixtures |
The Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty (CTBT) relies on monitoring systems that detect fission products like Ba-140 and La-140 to verify compliance 1 .
La-140 measurements help operators characterize irradiated nuclear fuel and determine power distribution in fuel rods 3 .
Study of fission fragments drives fundamental scientific discoveries about nuclear structure and astrophysical processes 2 .
"Research has shown that precise measurement of the La-140/Ba-140 ratio can date nuclear events within a window of just hours—a critical capability for distinguishing tests from other radiation sources and holding violators accountable."
The JCO criticality accident represents a dark chapter in nuclear history, but the scientific response exemplifies how we can extract valuable knowledge from disaster.
The clever application of La-140/Ba-140 measurements transformed a radioactive byproduct into a precise nuclear clock, enabling researchers to quantify the accident's scale long after the chain reactions had ceased.
This forensic approach has since become part of a broader scientific toolkit that supports everything from nuclear safety to international security. As detection technology advances—with more sensitive spectrometers and more sophisticated analysis techniques—our ability to read these natural nuclear clocks continues to improve.
The story of La-140 in the JCO investigation reminds us that even in the aftermath of tragedy, careful science can provide clarity, accountability, and ultimately, the knowledge to prevent future disasters.
References will be added here in the format: 1 Author, Year, Journal